Fans of Travis Kelce are reacting to new pictures that have gone viral on the internet, showing him kissing another woman at a hotel. Some are saying that he’s cheating on Taylor Swift and questioning his faithfulness

with the pop superstar.

Asked by Zias who he would kiss, marry or kill, the Kansas City Chiefs tight end, 34 — who was promoting his reality dating show Catching Kelce at the time — responded that he would “kiss” Swift.”Are you gonna marry, kiss or kill me / It’s just a game, but really / I’m bettin’ on all three for us two,” she sings on the love song “So High School,” which is laced with plenty of other Easter eggs from throughout her romance with the athlete.

Zias tells PEOPLE exclusively she was flooded by messages on Instagram when she woke up on Friday, April 19, after fans latched onto the lyric.

“In the smallest way, I and I couldn’t be more excited. People [were] freaking out for me, and when I heard it I gasped and then said, ‘No, it couldn’t be!’” she says. “And now I keep getting tagged in videos about it, so it must be real. I am so honored. There is no one more iconic than Taylor Swift, and to think I even influenced her a bit thrills me.”

Zias jokes that she “put the idea of Taylor Swift in Travis’ head” back in 2016 and that she wants to “officiate the wedding.”